Aid has begun to arrive in besieged town; health experts say door-to-door checks on starving civilians needed
The suffering in the besieged Syrian town of Madaya is the worst seen in thecountry’s civil war, the United Nations said Tuesday, a day after the first aid convoys started to reach starving civilians cuf off from the outside world for months.
“There is no comparison in what we saw in Madaya,” the UN refugee agency’s chief in Damascus, Sajjad Malik, told journalists in Geneva, when asked to compare the devastation in the town to other areas in Syria.
He said there were “credible reports” of people starving to death during the months-long siege by pro-regime forces.
Syria’s ambassador to the United Nations, Bashar Jaafari, told journalists in New York on Monday that there was “no starvation in Madaya” after the medical charity Doctors Without Borders (MSF) said 28 people in the town had starved to death since Dec 1..
“There was no life,” said Malik, who was in the convoy, describing a town of desperate people who in many cases were too weak to voice outrage over their suffering.
Concern has turned to providing much-needed aid to those suffering in the city. The World Health Organization (WHO) has asked the Syrian government for permission to send mobile clinics and medical teams to the besieged town of Madaya to assess the extent of malnutrition and evacuate the worst cases, its representative said Tuesday.
Elizabeth Hoff, WHO representative in Damascus who went into Madaya on Monday in the convoy, said the agency needed to do a “door-to-door assessment” in the town of 42,000 people, where a Syrian doctor told her 300-400 needed “special medical care.”
“I am really alarmed,” Hoff said, speaking by telephone from the Syrian capital where the health expert has been based since July 2012.
“People gathered in the market place. You could see many were malnourished, starving. They were skinny, tired, severely distressed. There was no smile on anybody’s face. It is not what you see when you arrive with a convoy. The children I talked to said they had no strength to play.”
On Monday, the WHO brought in 7.8 tons of medicine including trauma kits for wounds, medicines for treating both chronic and communicable diseases, and antibiotics and nutritional therapeutic supplies for children, Hoff said.
The organization intends to return on Thursday as part of a U.N. convoy with more medical and food supplies, she said.
The Syrian Observatory for Human Rights, an activist group that monitors the war, said at least 300 people left the town and were taken by government forces to the Damascus region. The U.N. said its vehicles were not used to take anyone out of Madaya.
Hoff said another Syrian doctor had told her that “mothers had absolutely no milk for breast-feeding, the milk had dried up and the babies are not satisfied.”
“The female doctor also reported having done 27-30 C-sections (caesarean sections) in the past seven months. She does not have the requisite training, but she saw it as a life-saving intervention,” Hoff said.
Many malnourished people were too weak to leave their homes.
“We need to go in with the Syrian Arab Red Crescent for a door-to-door assessment, if there are these cases we need to verify and make sure they get urgent treatment,” Hoff said. “I sent an immediate request to authorities for more supplies to be brought in. We are asking for mobile clinics and medical teams to be dispatched.”
She added: “We need unhindered, sustained access, the only thing that will help in the long term is lifting the siege.”
Hoff visited two medical sites in Madaya, one a private practice based in a home run by two doctors, and the other a makeshift field hospital in a basement. Neither had supplies.
“The doctors at the private practice said they had run out of medicines they received in October and patients preferred to spend what little money they had on food and not health care,” Hoff said. “They reported widespread malnutrition and serious problems with severe acute malnutrition. I cannot confirm what they reported.”
The makeshift field hospital, down a dark flight of stairs, lacked hygienic conditions, Hoff said. “The room is often so crowded that they had to give a drip to a patient outdoors because there was no room in the clinic.”
The two doctors at the private clinic told her that they see patients with “acute respiratory infections, urinary tract infections and anemia,” she said. Others had low blood sugar.
“An elderly lady had not eaten for 20 days, she was picked up unconscious on the street and brought in. She had bruises from the fall. She was severely undernourished.”
The first Syrian doctor there told her he had names of 300-400 people requiring immediate medical care. “The doctor in the clinic reported that he hadn’t eaten for three days.”
“I spoke with a man who said he was 45 and severely malnourished, he could hardly talk. He said he had four children at home who are in a bad situation. He was totally dehydrated and had a yellow color and was distressed.”
“A pregnant woman was there who came in regularly unconscious … she was lying in front of me, with very low blood sugar and lacking food. The nurse had nothing to give.”
The WHO simultaneously delivered 3.9 tons each to Foua and Kafraya, two villages in Idlib province encircled by Syrian rebels who are fighting the government.